This Week's Puzzle

This assignment is due before 9 AM, Friday, September 22nd, 2000.



  • Puzzle solutions are due by 9:00 AM on Friday of each week.
  • Puzzles are worth 5 points of extra credit each.
  • Answers must be accompanied by valid reasoning. Just like the tests, the answer alone isn't enough!
  • Each week, the first student to submit a correct answer will recieve the stylish 251 T-shirt.
  • Previous winners get a "virtual t-shirt." No shirt, but a chance to win a prize with actual value at the end of the semester (often a book, or maybe software).
  • Please enter your solution in the text area at the bottom of this page. DON'T FORGET TO GIVE YOUR NAME!

"Symmetry"

Consider the figure above. The blue balls are located at (-1,1,0) and (1,-1,0) each carry a charge, Q. The green balls are located at (1,1,0) and (-1,-1,0). They each carry a charge -Q. There are three points marked in red, O is the origin, P1 is (0,0,2) and P2 is (2,0,0). There are no charges at these points. I would like to rank the points O, P1, and P2 in order of decreasing electric field strength. The correct answer is:

  1. P1>P2>O
  2. O>P1>P2
  3. P1>O>P2
  4. O>P2>P1
  5. O>P2=P1
  6. P2>P1=O
  7. P2>P1>O
  8. P1=P2>O
  9. The fields are all equal
  10. None of the above

Don't forget to explain your answer as clearly as possible.


This site is made possible by funding from the National Science Foundation (DUE-9981111).

©2000 IUPUI, all rights reserved.
©2001 A. Gavrin and G. Novak, all rights reserved.